Is female circumcision (FGM) permitted in Islam?
Someone from Egypt wrote to Hazrat Amirul Momineen, Khalifatul Masih V (aa), enquiring whether female circumcision is permissible.
Huzoor-e-Anwar (aa), in his letter dated 15 April 2024, provided the following reply:
“Neither the Holy Quran nor the blessed ahadith contain any command to circumcise women. Male circumcision, however, has been declared part of fitrah or human nature. Accordingly, Hazrat Abu Hurairah (ra) narrates in Sahih al-Bukhari that the Holy Prophet (sa) said that five practices are part of fitrah: circumcision, removing pubic hair, removing underarm hair, trimming the nails and clipping the moustache. (Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-libas, Bab qassi sh-sharib, [Hadith 5891]; Sahih Bukhari with Urdu Translation and Commentary, Vol. 14, Farnham, 2023, p. 320)
“Male circumcision is an established practice of the Muslim Ummah. In the case of female circumcision, however, we find no continuous practice originating from the time of the Holy Prophet (sa). As for the two or three ahadith that mention female circumcision, scholars of Hadith have criticised their narrators, describing some as majhul (meaning a narrator whose identity cannot be determined with certainty) and mudallis (a narrator who relates a report from a contemporary in a manner suggesting that they personally heard it from that narrator, although they did not hear it directly from the original narrator). They have classified these ahadith as da‘if (meaning a hadith that fails to meet one or more of the conditions required for an authentic narration) and munqati‘ (meaning a hadith in which a link is missing from the middle of the chain of transmission). (‘Awn al-Ma‘bud: Sharh Sunan Abi Dawud, Kitab al-adab, Bab ma ja’a fi l-khitan)
“Before the advent of Islam, female circumcision was practised among certain Arab tribes, just as it is still practised in some parts of Africa today. However, Islamic law has nowhere commanded female circumcision.
“Those who advocate female circumcision describe reducing sexual desire as one of its purposes. Yet sexual desire in both men and women is itself a natural endowment from Allah the Exalted. Islam has nowhere prescribed anything contrary to human nature. It has, however, provided various instructions to direct these natural inclinations towards their proper course. Adornment, too, is part of a woman’s nature. Islam has not forbidden her from this either, but has instructed her to adorn herself for her husband and not to appear adorned before non-mahram men, as this may give rise to social ills, which is contrary to Islamic teachings.
“If the purpose of circumcision is to eliminate a woman’s sexual desire altogether and thereby enslave her, this too is contrary to Islamic teachings, for Islam has taught against slavery and repeatedly commanded the freeing of slaves.
“During his Khilafat, Hazrat Umar (ra) was making his rounds through the streets of Medina one night when he heard a woman in a house reciting impassioned verses about her separation from her husband. He asked her, ‘What is the matter?’ She replied, ‘My husband has been away at war for several months and now my longing for him has overwhelmed me.’ Hazrat Umar (ra) asked her, ‘You have not entertained any improper intention, have you?’ She replied, ‘I seek refuge with Allah!’ He said, ‘Restrain yourself. I shall send a messenger to summon your husband.’
“He sent a messenger to summon her husband and then went to Hazrat Hafsah (ra), saying, ‘I am going to ask you about something that has troubled me, so put my mind at ease. How long can a woman restrain herself without her husband?’ On hearing this, Hazrat Hafsah (ra) lowered her head out of modesty. Hazrat Umar (ra) said, ‘Allah the Exalted is not shy of the truth.’ At this, Hazrat Hafsah (ra) indicated with her hand three or four months. Hazrat Umar (ra) consequently sent instructions to his officials that no soldier should be kept away at war for more than four months. (Musannaf ‘Abd al-Razzaq, Vol. 7, p. 151, Hadith 12593; Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti, Tarikh al-Khulafa, Khilafat Umar ibn al-Khattab, Fasl fi nubadh min akhbarihi wa-qadayah)
“If circumcision eliminated a woman’s sexual desire altogether and female circumcision was widely practised in Arabia, why did this woman feel the need for physical intimacy with her husband?
“Thus, it is established that female circumcision was not a prevalent practice during the blessed time of the Holy Prophet (sa) and the Rightly Guided Caliphs. If it was practised in a particular region, it was merely a local custom and had no connection with Islamic teachings.”
Can a woman fast and pray with bleeding caused by uterine fibroids?

A woman wrote to Hazrat Amirul Momineen, Khalifatul Masih V (aa), stating:
“I had a miscarriage and the bleeding stopped after the period of postnatal bleeding [nifas] ended. However, I have been experiencing spotting since the beginning of Ramadan. My period is not yet due. I am also taking contraceptive pills. I have a uterine fibroid, which causes me to pass these blood clots. The doctors have advised me to rest for now, prescribed medication for this condition and scheduled an appointment for full treatment. At present, I am experiencing blood clots, backache and occasional abdominal spasms. My period is due to begin in a few days. Once my period ends, may I fast and offer prayers despite this condition? Prayer and fasting are very dear to me.”
Huzoor-e-Anwar (aa), in his letter dated 15 April 2024, provided the following guidance:
“The condition you have described falls within the category of illness [marad]. Allah the Exalted has granted those who are ill an exemption from fasting and instructed them to make up the same number of fasts later. (Surah al-Baqarah, Ch.2: V.185) Therefore, first complete your treatment and, once you have recovered, make up these fasts. If you have the financial means, you should also pay fidyah, i.e. the compensatory payment for missed fasts.
“You have written that the doctor has also prescribed medication for your illness. Some medicines require a person to drink more water. If you fast, you will be unable to drink water. In any case, even if you do not need to drink more water, you should rest fully, as your doctor has advised.
“As for passing blood clots or experiencing spotting, this is an illness rather than menstruation. Therefore, in accordance with the guidance of the Holy Prophet (sa), you should continue to offer your prayers in this condition, performing fresh ablution for each prayer. (Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-wudu, Bab ghusli d-dam; Sahih Bukhari with Urdu Translation and Commentary, Vol. 1, Farnham, 2019, pp. 310-311)
“Thus, while offering prayers during illness remains mandatory, fasting is excused, since the fasts can be made up later.”
Must women make up all Ramadan fasts missed during pregnancy and breastfeeding?

A woman from Jordan asked Hazrat Amirul Momineen, Khalifatul Masih V (aa), whether a pregnant or breastfeeding woman is exempt from making up the fasts of the Ramadans that pass during her pregnancy or breastfeeding, being required to make up only the fasts of the last Ramadan she was unable to observe, rather than those of earlier Ramadans.
Huzoor-e-Anwar (aa), in his letter dated 17 April 2024, provided the following reply:
“The fundamental point is that fasting is an act of worship and performing this act of worship during Ramadan brings greater blessings. However, if circumstances prevent a person from fasting, these fasts can also be made up throughout the year according to their capacity and strength. Therefore, once a pregnant or nursing woman has completed her pregnancy and breastfeeding, if she has the strength to fast, she may gradually make up the fasts missed in previous years over the next few years, during the months outside Ramadan, according to her capacity and strength. If, however, she does not have the strength to make up all these fasts, she should observe as many as she can. And if she has the financial means, she should in any case pay fidyah.
“Providing guidance on making up fasts missed over several previous years, Hazrat Musleh-e-Maud (ra) states:
“‘I wish to advise the Jamaat that those friends who did not observe all the fasts of Ramadan should observe them later and complete them, whether they were missed through negligence, illness or travel. Similarly, if they missed any fasts in previous years through negligence or a valid religious excuse, they should endeavour to complete those too, so that they may have cleared their account before appearing before God Almighty.
“‘Some jurists hold that fasts missed in a previous year cannot be observed in the following year. In my view, however, if someone was unable to fast through lack of knowledge, that lack of knowledge may be forgiven. But if they deliberately did not fast, there is no making up for it, just as there is no making up for a prayer deliberately omitted. If, however, they missed the fasts through forgetfulness or an error in juristic reasoning, then, in my view, they may observe them later and it is better for them to do so.
“‘Indeed, if they were able to fast but deliberately did not do so, there is no making up for it. When they repent, their deeds will begin afresh. However, if they did not fast through negligence, an error in juristic reasoning or illness, then, in my view, those fasts may still be made up, however long ago they were missed.’
(Al Fazl, No. 55, Vol. 50-51, 8 March 1961, pp. 2-3)
“Thus, if someone has missed fasts from more than one Ramadan owing to a valid excuse and Allah the Exalted subsequently enables them to fast once that excuse has ceased, they should gradually make up as many of those missed fasts as they can.”
Should the hands be folded or left at the sides during salat?

Someone from Libya asked Hazrat Amirul Momineen, Khalifatul Masih V (aa), whether, after the takbir-e-tahrimah [the opening declaration of ‘Allahu Akbar’] in salat, they should fold their hands on their chest or leave them at their sides.
Huzoor-e-Anwar (aa), in his letter dated 23 April 2024, provided the following reply:
“No instruction to leave the hands at one’s sides during the standing posture [qiyam] of prayer is established from the Holy Prophet (sa). Rather, the authentic books of Hadith record his sunnah as keeping his hands folded during qiyam. Accordingly, Hazrat Sahl bin Sa‘d (ra) narrates that people were instructed to place their right hand over their left arm during prayer. Abu Hazim (the narrator reporting from Hazrat Sahl bin Sa‘d [ra]) states, ‘My understanding is that he (Sahl) attributed this instruction to the Holy Prophet (sa).’ (Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-adhan, Bab wad‘i l-yumna ‘ala l-yusra fi s-salat, [Hadith 740]; Sahih Bukhari with Urdu Translation and Commentary, Vol. 2, Farnham, 2019, p. 142)
“Similarly, Hazrat Wa’il bin Hujr (ra) narrates that he saw the Holy Prophet (sa), upon beginning salat, pronounce the takbir-e-tahrimah and then place his right hand over his left. (Sahih Muslim, Kitab as-salat, Bab wad‘i yadihi l-yumna ‘ala l-yusra ba‘da takbirati l-ihram)
“The majority of jurists agree that the hands should be folded during the qiyam of prayer rather than left at the sides. However, the view that the hands should be left at the sides during qiyam is attributed to Hazrat Imam Malik (rh).
“What was the practice of our master, the Promised Messiah (as), the Just Arbiter [Hakam ‘Adl] of this age, in this regard? Hazrat Syed Muhammad Sarwar Shah (ra) relates:
“‘When (the Promised Messiah [as]) offers salat, he faces the Ka‘bah and, saying “Allahu Akbar”, raises both hands until his fingers are level with his ears. He then lowers both hands and folds them on his chest, that is, over the breasts or immediately below them, with the left hand underneath and the right hand on top. Usually, the tips of the three middle fingers of his right hand reach his left elbow or fall slightly short of it, while his thumb and little finger clasp the arm. However, if someone folds their hands differently, placing them higher or lower, extending them further or drawing them back or clasping the arm with all their fingers, no one objects.’
(Risalah Talim-ul-Islam, Vol. 1, No. 5, Qadian, July 1906, pp. 171, 176-180; Ashab-e-Ahmad, Vol. 5, pp. 542-543)
“Thus, the sunnah of the Holy Prophet (sa) and the established practice of his most ardent devotee, the Promised Messiah (as), is to offer salat with the hands folded during qiyam.”
Is it permissible to raise the hands for du‘a after salat?

Someone from the UK wrote to Hazrat Amirul Momineen, Khalifatul Masih V (aa), referring to an answer Huzoor (aa) had given during a question-and-answer session about du‘a after salat and requested guidance about that answer.
Huzoor-e-Anwar (aa), in his letter dated 23 April 2024, provided the following reply:
“The fundamental point is that one may supplicate to Allah the Exalted at any time; there is no restriction whatsoever. Sometimes a person experiences a state in which they feel that it is a moment for the acceptance of prayer. Whether this occurs during the formal prayer, afterwards or at any other time, there is absolutely no restriction on supplicating at that moment. However, as the Promised Messiah (as) himself explained very clearly, a widespread innovation has developed in India whereby people do not offer the formal prayer properly and then begin supplicating as a customary ritual once it has ended. The Promised Messiah (as) forbade the Jamaat from this practice. Accordingly, he states:
“‘I observe that the manner in which people offer salat nowadays amounts to nothing more than striking their heads against the ground. Their salat does not contain even as much tenderness of heart and spiritual delight as they display when raising their hands in supplication afterwards. Would that they offered their supplications within the formal prayer itself! Perhaps their prayers would then acquire presence of heart and spiritual delight.
“‘Therefore, I instruct you, as a directive, to refrain altogether for the time being from supplicating after salat. Instead, by offering your supplications within salat, cultivate there the delight and presence of heart that you have reserved for those [post-salat] supplications. I do not mean that supplicating after salat is forbidden. Rather, I desire that, until sufficient delight and presence of heart have developed within your salat, you should not forfeit its delight by supplicating afterwards. Once that presence of heart has developed, however, there is no harm.’
(Malfuzat, Vol. 6, UK, 2022, p. 202)
“Similarly, he (as) states elsewhere:
“‘The truth is that we do not forbid supplication; we ourselves also supplicate. Indeed, salat is, in and of itself, supplication. The point is that I have advised my Jamaat concerning a widespread innovation in India: people do not give full attention to the proper and unhurried performance of the prayer postures and offer a hurried, “pecking” prayer, as though it were a tax whose payment is a burden. They therefore perform it reluctantly, whereas salat is something that should increase spiritual relish, intimacy and joy. Yet the manner in which it is offered fails to bring about presence of heart and instead produces a lack of relish and delight.
“‘This is the very advice I have given my Jamaat: they should not offer a salat that produces an absence of spiritual relish and presence of heart. Rather, they should strive for presence of heart, so that they may attain joy and spiritual relish. Generally, people offer salat without striving for presence of heart, hurrying to finish it. Then, outside salat, they make considerable efforts in supplication and continue supplicating for a long time, whereas the very purpose of salat, which is the believer’s spiritual ascension, is that one should supplicate within it.’
(Malfuzat, Vol. 3, UK, 2022, p. 239)
“Thus, there is no harm in supplicating. However, it is necessary to avoid the ritualised manner of supplication that has emerged as an innovation among Muslims in this age, so that attention may be directed towards the true purpose and objective of supplication.”
(Submitted by Ehsan Ahmad, Murabbi-e-Silsilah, Private Secretariat, Islamabad and translated by Al Hakam)
